Highnotes

Home

Screenplay Excerpts from

High Notes

Tyler Craft Cormney

Author’s Note:

Tony Pagliacci, a rootless countertenor, might seem an unlikely hero. In the original comedy High Notes, this struggling American opera singer travels to Italy to reconnect with his roots and to find the poetry that is missing in his day-to-day life.

 In the opening scene, we find our nostalgic icon in the throes of a passionate daydream. Throughout the film, we travel between dream and reality, past and present; sometimes it is difficult to tell which is which:

The score for the aria “Vesti La Giubba” from Leoncavallo’s opera I PAGLIACCI begins over BLACK.

FADE IN:

INT. LA SCALA OPERA HOUSE - MILAN, ITALY - NIGHT

We travel through the auditorium of the most famous opera house in all the world: ornate white ceilings, sculptures, the plaster masks of Comedy and Tragedy.

THE AUDITORIUM

is filled to capacity with finely dressed ITALIAN PATRONS, their faces eager with anticipation.

CENTER STAGE

A light comes up on the clown, PAGLIACCIO, separating him from matted darkness. He looks up. His eyes sparkle with tears as he begins Canio’s famous lament, “Vesti la Giubba” --

PAGLIACCIO (THE CLOWN)

“Recitar! Mentre presso dal delirio...

The singer has an unusually high tenor voice. Technically, he’s a countertenor, and the Aria was composed for a standard tenor, so we are witnessing a singular performance. PAGLIACCIO’S song continues to the final stanza:

PAGLIACCIO (THE CLOWN)

 ...Tramuta in lazzi lo spasmo ed il pianto; in una smorfia il singhiozzo e’l dolor. Oh ridi, Pagliaccio, sul tuo amore in franto!”

Tears stream down his cheeks. He drops to one knee and opens his arms to the heavens:

PAGLIACCIO (cont’d)

(singing the finale)

“Ridi del duol t’avvelena il cor!”

Pagliaccio bows his head.

We hear the THUNDERING APPLAUSE of the opera house.

Suddenly, and all at once, the round of applause ends.

Silence.

The Clown looks up. In a flash, his fantasy world disintegrates:

We hear the clink of silverware, muffled chatter, bawdy laughter.

THE CLOWN’S POV - LA SCALA OPERA HOUSE

is now a dingy dinner theater. The enthralled OPERA FANS have been replaced by indifferent DINERS, stuffing their faces, slurping their wine, cracking their ribald jokes.

COSTUMED WAITERS weave among the tables pouring cheap chianti: AN ENGLISH DANDY, A VIKING PRINCESS, A GYPSY GIRL CHOMPING A CIGAR.

THE CLOWN looks down at his own costume. It is now an ill-fitting moth-eaten, button-missing replica of the ornate costume from his fantasy. The sadness in the Clown’s eyes is heartbreaking, but this is no longer an act. His head hangs low as he starts off stage. Then --

A well-dressed ITALIAN GENTLEMAN at a table near the stage begins to clap for him. He’s the only one. In fact, he stands up from his table while applauding.

The Clown pauses and smiles, tipping his bowler hat.

The Curtain falls. Its surface proudly proclaiming:

“LA SCALA RISTORANTE, NEW YORK
Home of the Singing Waiter”

INT. THE WINGS - SAME

A step off stage, the Clown’s smile vanishes and his shoulders slump. He passes the next dreamer waiting for her cue, a rotund VIKING PRINCESS. To her he doesn’t exist -- there are no Italian clowns in her opera.

 

When he learns that his biological mother is dying, Tony travels to the fictional city of Santa Cecilia, Italy, to say farewell. This will be their first meeting since she gave him up for adoption twenty years ago. He has so many questions, but she is too weak to speak anything more than the name she gave him. For now, his questions must remain unanswered.

Like a detective, Tony searches Santa Cecilia for clues that will give him some indication of who his mother was, and, perhaps, who he is in the process. Leonardo Mazza, who becomes Tony’s guide and confidant, tells him that “the very soul of Santa Cecilia is music... At least it used to be.”

The city of Santa Cecilia is tottering on the brink of the twenty-first century. The standards of its golden era are rapidly disappearing. As another character puts it, “It used to be in Italy there were two powers you did not crossGod and Opera.” But times have apparently changed: Santa Cecilia’s Opera House has been condemned and is scheduled to be demolished. In Violetta’s words from the opera La Traviata, it is time to say “addio, del passato bei sogni ridenti”---“farewell past, happy dreams of days gone by.”

Tony learns that his mother was once an opera singer, who couldn’t make ends meet. Even after giving him up for adoption, she was forced to leave the stage to earn a living wage. Through determination, she built a costume shop that served the local opera house. If she couldn’t be on the stage, at least her beautiful creations would be. Now, with the opera house closed, her legacy is in jeopardy.

Tony visits the costume shop, which was left to him in his mother’s will. Inside he meets ghosts of the past, clowns of the present, and a vision of the future:

INT. COSTUME SHOP - NIGHT

Tony enters. The shop is dimly lit and deserted.

THE COSTUMES

look like a royal court of headless ghosts.

MUSIC is playing softly from the back of the shop.

Tony listens at the door of his mother’s office. The music is coming from inside. He opens the door.

INT. THE OFFICE - SAME

The song is “Un Aura Amorosa” from Mozart’s Cosi Fan Tutte.

When Tony enters, he sees --

A MAN’S ARMS hugging the waist of a DRESS DUMMY.

TONY

Excuse me.

Rodolfo, the street singer, releases the dress dummy and jumps back.

RODOLFO

(blushing)

Mi scusi! Mi scusi!

TONY

What are you doing?

Rodolfo, tipping his top hat repeatedly --

RODOLFO

Buona notte! Buona notte! Quack quack!

He runs out past Tony. Tony shakes his head. He stops the record player. The music stops.

DISSOLVE TO:

INT. THE OFFICE - A FEW MINUTES LATER

A lonely cot in the corner and a rack of women’s clothes.

BLACK AND WHITE PHOTOS

of his mother with various opera stars on the wall.

Tony pulls a framed photo from the wall.

THE PHOTO

is of his mother, twenty years ago. She’s standing next to a young LUIGI CANTINORI in his Pagliacci costume.

TONY (V.O.)

Cantinori...

CUT TO:

A BABY ALBUM

Pictures of Tony as an infant. He stops on --

A PHOTOGRAPH

Tony, age three, facing his mother, who is the same age as she was in the photo with Cantinori. She’s dressed in the white gown she was wearing in Tony’s nightmare on the plane. Her hands cup his tiny face.

Tony touches his tingling cheeks as if remembering.

BABY ALBUM

After this page, the rest are blank.

Tony opens the blinds of a window facing the shop floor.

THE SHOP FLOOR

The costumes look so empty without bodies inside them.

Tony’s eyes reveal the loneliness in his heart. He turns away from the window and notices something that he wasn’t conscious of before --

THE DRESS DUMMY

that Rodolfo was hugging is draped in a WHITE GYPSY GOWN, the same dress seen in the album photo and in Tony’s nightmare.

Tony closes the office blinds.

ANOTHER ANGLE - THE RECORD PLAYER

Tony lowers the needle. The music begins again, “Un Aura Amorosa.”

ANOTHER ANGLE - TONY AND THE DRESS DUMMY

He carefully wraps his arms around the dress dummy and sways gently with the music.

Moments later, a woman’s voice interrupts him:

WOMAN’S VOICE (O.S.)

Mi scusi.

Tony, still holding the dress dummy, spins around, half-expecting to see his mother’s ghost.

ANGELINA BIRENZE

is about his age. Her devastating beauty is accentuated by the vulnerability of a lost child.

ANGELINA

(in Italian, subtitled)

<Is the Signorina in?>

Tony steps around the dress dummy.

TONY

She’s...No. Can I help you?

ANGELINA

Mi dispiace. English. Am I late?

Her English is very good.

TONY

For what?

ANGELINA

My lesson.

TONY

Sorry...?

Pause.

ANGELINA

Just tell her that I stopped by.

She starts to go.

TONY

What’s your name?

ANGELINA

(laughing nervously)

Oh. Angelina Birenze.

Angelina turns, intent on leaving.

TONY

Signorina Birenze, wait.

Angelina turns back to face him.

TONY (cont’d)

I’m sorry to be the one to tell you...Signorina Cassini has passed away.

Angelina clutches her heart.

ANGELINA

Oh...Oh no!

TONY

You...studied with her?

ANGELINA

Not...no. I met her on a train at the beginning of the summer. I’ve been away. I’ve just -- she told me to come when I -- Ah Dio. Poor woman.

She crosses herself.

TONY

She was my mother.

Angelina bursts into tears.

ANGELINA

I feel...I -- dispiace.

Angelina runs out of the office. Tony chases after her --

TONY

Signorina!

 

Tony embarks on a quest through the past for beauty. He finds it represented in the condemned Opera House, in the costume shop that his mother built with her own hands, and in the person of Angelina Birenze, a vulnerable, young Italian woman who is searching for her own share of beauty and independence. High Notes is a film about searching our past for answers.

Tony falls in love with Angelina, but she is engaged to Enzo Stavione, the most powerful man in Santa Cecilia. Enzo also happens to be the real estate developer responsible for closing the opera house and trying to put Tony’s mother’s costume shop out of business. When Tony stands up to Enzo, his life is endangered. In order to stay in Santa Cecilia, he must disguise himself as a female singing tutor named Mona Lisa.

EXT. UNIVERSITY CAMPUS - SANTA CECILIA - DAY

The love duet from Puccini’s Madame Butterfly --

“Vogliatemi bene” -- plays over.

Mona Lisa makes her debut on campus. It’s a magical day when anything seems possible --

A violet sky, majestic poplar trees, a monarch butterfly.

Mona Lisa’s long, yellow scarf flutters in the wind.

“She” sees a group of six YOUNG WOMEN sitting on a picnic blanket having tea.

THE TEA PARTY

In Tony’s mind’s eye, the tea party becomes a Picasso painting -- a cubist tea party: glimpses of pastel colored sundresses. A tea cup of bone china. A woman’s eye. A steaming tea pot. Pink lips. Sun reflected off long hair. A delicate hand. A plate of sweets. The silhouette of a woman’s neck and shoulder.

Then in the next moment, disparate images combine into a unity of beauty -- Angelina Birenze.

Angelina notices Mona Lisa staring at her. She stands up from the tea party and crosses to her.

Mona Lisa smiles at Angelina, and Angelina returns the smile.

 

Tony eventually learns that he must drop his mask if he is ever going to find true love. When Angelina learns that she has been deceived, she is understandably furious. Nevertheless, she recognizes that his motives were pure. In true operatic fashion, she lets him know that he is forgiven by singing a love duet that he composed for her. The aria is written with male and female parts interchanging but never overlappingthat is, until the end. High Notes ends like the aria, in harmony:

EXT. THE PARK - DUSK

A light snow is falling.

A haggard, bearded, half-dead Tony Pagliacci sings for loose change and huddles for body warmth.

On the wind, Tony thinks he hears a --

WOMAN SINGING.

He’s delirious -- It may be his imagination.

TONY

Papa did you hear...Papa?

Tony looks around, but he’s alone.

He hears the song again and stumbles in the direction of the woman’s voice.

EXT. STREETS OF SANTA CECILIA - SAME

He searches the winding streets. Suddenly, he’s aware that this is the female part of Angelina’s aria.

Tony struggles to sing the reply but can’t; his voice has deserted him.

The Woman’s voice leads him to --

INT. THE OPERA HOUSE - SAME

A light comes up on stage and we see a WOMAN’S SILHOUETTE behind the scrim.

Tony, exhausted and dressed in rags, climbs onto the stage and stands on the other side of the scrim.

He touches the silhouette lightly with his hand, certain it must be a mirage.

The woman sings softly.

Tony falls to his knees, removes his hat, and holds it out to her. Angelina’s singing the final stanza of the aria he wrote for her -- THE HARMONY.

LEO, ESTELLA, RODOLFO, AND OTHERS

slip into the House quietly, unnoticed by Tony.

TONY

unties the moth-eaten scarf wrapped around his throat.

With all he has left, he attempts to join her song.

HIS VOICE

is brittle at first but slowly regains its former power.

THE SCRIM rises revealing --

ANGELINA

breathtaking in Tony’s mother’s white gypsy gown, the one that Rodolfo rescued from the fire.

HIS TIRED EYES

ignite with a new spark. Tony moves closer to her. She takes his free hand --

Their voices soar together. The song concludes.

Angelina holds his face in her hands, the same way that Tony’s mother did in the old photograph.

APPLAUSE rises from the House.

Angelina looks into the audience and sees --

HER FATHER

shaking his fist above his head in emphatic celebration.

Angelina takes a bow.

LEO AND ESTELLA

smile at one another. Estella takes Leo’s hand.

RODOLFO

smiles as tears fall from his eyes.

TONY AND ANGELINA

bow, hand-in-hand.

TONY

takes a bow. He motions to Angelina. She takes a bow.

Tony takes a final bow worthy of Chaplin’s Little Tramp.

After a beat, he wipes away a single tear from his cheek --

TONY

(singing)

“La commedia e finita!”

The scrim falls in front of Tony and Angelina. We see their silhouettes come together in a kiss, and we --

FADE TO BLACK.

THE END.

 

Like Tony Pagliacci, we may learn that the beauty we are looking for is not behind us but inside us. We may discover that in order to possess this beauty we must reinvent ourselves, take chances, and break all the rules.